Linkages
to Finance
Lack of access to finance is a major bottleneck
for potential and existing entrepreneurs planning to start or
grow their businesses. One of the findings from the impact evaluation
conducted by the Regional Project Office in 1997 was that in
many cases potential entrepreneurs failed to start businesses
due to lack of start-up capital. Many respondents in fact quoted
lack of access to finance as the main reason why they did not
implement their business plans. Earlier impact evaluations conducted
for IYB beneficiaries had confirmed that entrepreneurs faced
similar bottlenecks: They often failed to grow their businesses
after IYB training because they did not secure funds.
Linking SIYB Graduates
to Financing Institutions
Acknowledging that access to finance is key to business start
up and growth, the programme explored avenues for linking
the SIYB beneficiaries to financing institutions. Beginning
1998, the ILO established a "linkages to finance"
component to SIYB whose objectives are to:
- build and maintain a network of linkages
between SIYB training providers on one hand and financing
institutions on the other, in the project countries.
- establish effective links for SIYB
training and credit schemes operated by local SIYB training
providers. The ILO based this linkage on the assumption
that properly managed collaboration between finance institutions
and (SIYB) training institutions is highly beneficial to
both parties and in the direct interest of the small-scale
entrepreneurs. There is ample reason to support this hypothesis:
- Financing institutions directly benefit
from such linkages since they can refer loan applicants
to business start-up and management training first. Such
clients lower the risk of defaulting on loan repayments
because SIYB training assists them to develop thorough business
plans, or to structure their business operations properly.
- On the other hand, SIYB training providers
also benefit because they are able to offer their clients
much more than mere training. In the eyes of their clients,
referral services add significant value to the corporate
service portfolio and make the SIYB training product more
relevant to their needs.
- Potential and existing entrepreneurs
benefit from the combined efforts of training providers
and financing institutions working together since they are
able to directly approach the latter after SIYB training
for funding. SIYB acknowledges that there should be no automatic
link between training and access to credit.
Progress made in Creating
Linkages Relationships
In 1998 the Regional Project Office conducted promotion workshops
targeting organizations in the formal and informal banking
and finance sectors e.g. commercial banks, NGO's and other
non-profit credit as well as donor agencies. The objective
of these workshops was to introduce the banking and finance
industry to the SIYB programme and to the training providers
as well to discuss the potential and benefits of collaboration.
After these discussions, suitable institutions were then selected
for networking. In many cases, these networks have resulted
in the establishment of formal linkages.
Linkages Best Practice: Experiences
from Zimbabwe
Zimbabwe (see project countries) is one example where training
providers, financing institutions and a dZimbabwe,
Nissi Finance (Pvt) (Ltd) and the community banking section
of CBZ are the micro-finance institutions. The Credit Guarantee
Company of Zimbabwe is also a network partner of the linkage
programme.
To start the collaboration, individual meetings were conducted
with each finance institution. Next, SIYB trainers (essentially
consultants from the private sector) were introduced to these
finance institutions through a workshop held in February 1999.
In the Zimbabwe model, private sector trainers were selected
because they are unencumbered by organizational structures
and thus respond quicker in meeting entrepreneurs’ needs
and also they use SIYB to generate revenues for their own
companies. Both the finance institutions and trainers were
introduced to HIVOS Foundation, a Dutch NGO that had agreed
to support entrepreneurial training in Zimbabwe by subsidizing
SIYB training on a declining scale over a 3 year period..
More than 400 entrepreneurs have since benefited from these
linkages between finance institutions and SIYB private trainers.
These entrepreneurs were referred from the commercial banks
and the micro-finance institutions to the training providers
and trained with financial support from HIVOS.
Exciting spin-offs: The SIYB Credit
Counselors programme
One spin-off from these linkages is the SIYB Credit Counselors
Training programme. During initial discussions on possible
collaboration, some micro-finance institutions expressed interest
in having their credit officers trained in business management.
Rather than planning to embark on their own SIYB training
programme in the future, the institutions wanted to prepare
their credit officers to assist loan applicants to better
plan businesses.
The justification was that credit officers would develop a
much better understanding of their clients’ business
problems from SIYB training. They would also be able to advise
clients more effectively. They would also be in a position
to decide if their clients were in need of full SIYB training
and to refer them to appropriate training.
The Regional Project Office developed a pilot SIYB Credit
Counselors Training programme. Between 1998 and 1999, 5 workshops
were conducted for micro-finance institutions in Ghana, Mozambique,
Uganda, Zambia and Zimbabwe. This training familiarized workshop
participants with the contents of the IYB materials (since
many micro-finance institutions mostly deal with clients already
in business) and on individual counseling techniques.
Impact of the Linkages Component
The July 1999 impact assessment showed that 20% of SIYB participants
in the six project countries submitted their business plans
for external financing. In 61% of the submitted cases, participants
were referred by the SIYB programme: 58% being the SIYB trainers
and 3% being the Directory of Advice and Assistance (see training
materials).
How to access SIYB
To obtain further information about the SIYB programme, please
contact:
ILO-SIYB Regional Project Office for Eastern and Southern
Africa
101 Kwame Nkrumah Avenue
P. O. Box 3474
Harare, Zimbabwe
secretariat@ilosiyb.co.zw
|